| Northeast Bracket | ||||
| 1998 Yankees (1) | '98 NYY | '98 NYY | '98 NYY | '98 NYY Northeast Champs |
| 1944 Browns (16) | ||||
| 1929 Cubs (8) | '90 OAK | |||
| 1990 A's (9) | ||||
| 1968 Tigers (5) | '68 DET | '46 BOS | ||
| 1985 Royals (12) | ||||
| 1946 Red Sox (4) | '46 BOS | |||
| 1994 Expos (13) | ||||
| 1957 Braves (6) | '57 MIL | '57 MIL | '86 NYM | |
| 1974 Dodgers (11) | ||||
| 1904 Giants (3) | '04 NYG | |||
| 1982 Brewers (14) | ||||
| 1977 Yankees (7) | '65 MIN | '86 NYM | ||
| 1965 Twins (10) | ||||
| 1986 Mets (2) | '86 NYM | |||
| 1999 Rangers (15) | ||||
| West Bracket | ||||
| 1975 Reds (1) | '75 CIN | '75 CIN | '75 CIN | '75 CIN West Champs |
| 1982 Angels (16) | ||||
| 1995 Indians (8) | '17 CWS | |||
| 1917 White Sox (9) | ||||
| 1951 Yankees (5) | '51 NYY | '51 NYY | ||
| 1980 Phillies (12) | ||||
| 1955 Dodgers (4) | '55 BKN | |||
| 1991 Twins (13) | ||||
| 1967 Cards (6) | '67 STL | '01 SEA | '01 SEA | |
| 1924 Senators (11) | ||||
| 2001 Mariners (3) | '01 SEA | |||
| 1986 Red Sox (14) | ||||
| 1973 A's (7) | '73 OAK | '84 SDG | ||
| 1979 Pirates (10) | ||||
| 1961 Yankees (2) | '84 SDG | |||
| 1984 Padres (15) | ||||
| Central Bracket | ||||
| 1906 Cubs (1) | '06 CHC | '06 CHC | '11 PHA | '70 BAL Central Champs |
| 1995 Rockies (16) | ||||
| 1940 Reds (8) | '60 PIT | |||
| 1960 Pirates (9) | ||||
| 1911 A's (5) | '11 PHA | '11 PHA | ||
| 1985 Cards (12) | ||||
| 1954 Giants (4) | '54 NYG | |||
| 1975 Red Sox (13) | ||||
| 1935 Tigers (6) | '01 NYY | '70 BAL | '70 BAL | |
| 2001 Yankees (11) | ||||
| 1970 Orioles (3) | '70 BAL | |||
| 1997 Marlins (14) | ||||
| 1963 Dodgers (7) | '93 TOR | '37 NYY | ||
| 1993 Blue Jays (10) | ||||
| 1937 Yankees (2) | '37 NYY | |||
| 1983 White Sox (15) | ||||
| East Bracket | ||||
| 1927 Yankees (1) | '27 NYY | '27 NYY | '27 NYY | '27 NYY East Champs |
| 1999 Devil Rays (16) | ||||
| 1918 Red Sox (8) | '62 SFO | |||
| 1962 Giants (9) | ||||
| 1954 Indians (5) | '54 CLE | '54 CLE | ||
| 1927 Pirates (12) | ||||
| 1934 Cards (4) | '34 STL | |||
| 2001 D-Backs (13) | ||||
| 1995 Braves (6) | '77 KCR | '84 DET | '83 BAL | |
| 1977 Royals (11) | ||||
| 1984 Tigers (3) | '85 DET | |||
| 1950 Phils (14) | ||||
| 1969 Mets (7) | '83 BAL | '83 BAL | ||
| 1983 Orioles (10) | ||||
| 1930 A's (2) | '86 HOU | |||
| 1986 Astros (15) | ||||
| Sim Series: The Final Four | ||||
| Northeast Bracket: 1998 New York Yankees (1) |
1975 Cincinnati Reds (The Big Red Machine) |
MLB Sim Series Champions: 1927 New York Yankees (4 Games to 3) |
1927 New York Yankees (Murders' Row) |
Central Bracket: 1970 Baltimore Orioles (3) |
| West Bracket: 1975 Cincinnati Reds (1) |
East Bracket: 1927 New York Yankees (1) |
|||
Reds 5, Yankees 4
Yankees 4, Reds 1
Reds 3, Yankees 2
Reds 12, Yankees 2
Yankees 9, Reds 7
Yankees 7, Reds 1
Yankees 6, Reds 5